Aside from Syesha, tonight was a complete disaster...

David “Combover” Cook sang “Hungry Like The Wolf”- The typical Hinderback performance from David. * and “Baba O’Riley”-Okay, this is my favorite Who song but I didn’t like the arrangement or David’s laid back take on the song. *1/2

Syesha sang “Proud Mary”- I hope she can pull some sort of upset and win the whole shebang, but I’m not holding my breath. This was a really solid performance with hints of outright greatness. *** and “A Change Is Gonna Come”-Hands down the best performance of at least the past month or so. Randy is insane.  ***1/2

Jason sang “I Shot The Sheriff”- Did you hear that rumbling down Jamaica way? That was Bob Marley rolling over in his grave. Absolutely one of the most horrific things ever heard on American Idol(and that’s saying something) ¼* and “Mr. Tambourine Man”- Not as bad as the Marley song, but still very tepid. Forgetting the lyrics is pretty inexcusable at this point. *1/2

David Archuleta sang “Stand By Me”- Shouldn’t you be required to have at least a little soul in your voice to sing this song? Gaspy is as whitebread as they come. * and “Love Me Tender”-He’s no Elvis..he’s not even dead Elvis…he’s not even a dead Elvis impersonator. *

Syesha was hands down the BEST
Castro was absolutely the WORST
I think we’ve seen the last of Jason and his Caucasian dreads.