Jason sang “Forever In Blue Jeans”- Sort of appealing in the most ingratiating way possible. ** and “September Morn”- Jason did better on this song, but still one dimensional. **1/2

David Cook sang “I’m Alive”- It went by so quickly that I forgot it as soon as it ended. * and “All I Really Need Is You”- More boredom. The judges are insane.*

Brooke sang “I’m A Believer”- Snoozefest, plain and simple. * and “I Am, I Said”-This is one of my favorite Neil Diamond songs, and Brooke did okay with it. Eh…**

David Archuleta sang “Sweet Caroline”- Sort of watered down karaoke meets high school talent show. *  and “America”- I’d like to defect. *

Syesha sang “Hello”- I liked this, despite her somewhat straightforward approach to the song. **1/2 and “Thank the Lord for the “Nighttime”- Not crazy about the song, but liked the performance. **1/2

Syesha was the BEST
Cook and Archuleta were the WORST.
I think Syesha is gone, though.