This was a terrible night. I'm talking AI6 levels of awfulness.

Mike Johns sang Dream On – I was impressed that he hit the high notes at the end. Other than that, it was just good and nothing more. Michael’s defensive attitude is wearing thin. ***

Syesha sang I Believe - Rainbows…pots of gold...shooting stars..dreaming…ahh sweet Disney mania. Yea I was completely indifferent to this performance. *

Jason sang Over The Rainbow – Take away the uke, and the performance was really average. Maybe he’ll break out the Dulcimer next week. **

KLC sang Anyway – Typical nu-country boredom. Another tepid performance from Amerikkka’s Sweetheart. ½*

David Cook sang Innocent – I pretty much hated every second of it. I liked that bit at the end when the song stopped, though. *

Carly sang The Show Must Go On – This is one of my favorite latter day Queen songs. Carly absolutely butchered it. This bordered on being painful to listen to. ½*

David Archuleta sang Angels – I liked it. Sue me. ***1/4

Brooke sang You’ve Got A Friend – This is a pop classic, but she didn’t do anything special with it. It’s kinda like buying a Picasso and hanging it in the garage. **

Best
David Archuleta
 

Worst
Almost everybody else…

Should Go
KLC or Carly
 

Will Go
Carly