Syesha sang some song called "One Rock and Roll Too Many"- Never heard of the song, but she sounded okay. A wee bit cutesy, but not unbearably bad or anything. **1/4

Jason sang "Memory"- To be fair, this is probably a really tough song to sing. To be blunt, Jason couldn't quite pull it off because his voice just isn't big enough. *1/2

Brooke sang "You Must Love Me"- I don't think I've ever seen someone start a song over during the five years I've been watching AI on a regular basis. It didn't really matter. Both her performance and the song were boring. *

Archuleta sang "Think Of Me"- Yet another schlocky piece of musical rice cake sang quite adequately by young Dave. **

Carly sang "Jesus Christ, Superstar"- This is probably the strangest song choice since Taylor Hicks did "Play That Funky Music" during AI5. It sort of worked on a very curious, unexplainable level.  **1/2

David Cook sang "Music of the Night"- God, how I hatre this song. David Combover didn't make me like it any better...*1/2

Syesha and Carly were the least offensive.

I'm guessing that we've seen the last of Brooke.